Agenda

Venue: Dean of Guild Court Room - City Chambers

Contact: Jamie Macrae  Blair Ritchie

Media

Items
No. Item

1. Order of business

Additional documents:

1.1

Order of Business

1.1       Including any notices of motion, hearing requests from ward councillors and any other items of business submitted as urgent for consideration at the meeting.

 

1.2       Any member of the Council can request a Hearing if an item raises a local issue affecting their ward. Members of the Sub-Committee can request a presentation on any items in part 4 or 5 of the agenda. Members must advise Committee Services of their request by no later than 1.00pm on Monday DATE (see contact details in the further information section at the end of this agenda).

 

1.3       If a member of the Council has submitted a written request for a hearing to be held on an application that raises a local issue affecting their ward, the Development Management Sub-Committee will decide after receiving a presentation on the application whether or not to hold a hearing based on the information submitted. All requests for hearings will be notified to members prior to the meeting.

 

 

Additional documents:

2. Declaration of interests

Additional documents:

2.1

Declaration of interests

Members should declare any financial and non-financial interests they have in the items of business for consideration, identifying the relevant agenda item and the nature of their interest.

 

Additional documents:

3. Minutes

Additional documents:

3.1

Minute of 15 March 2023 pdf icon PDF 289 KB

Minutes of Previous Meeting of Development Management Sub-Committee of 15 March 2023 – submitted for approval as a correct record

Additional documents:

3.2

Minute of 17 March 2023 pdf icon PDF 134 KB

Minutes of Previous Meeting of Development Management Sub-Committee of 17 March 2023 – submitted for approval as a correct record

 

Additional documents:

4. General Applications, Miscellaneous Business and Pre-Application Reports

Additional documents:

The key issues for the Pre-Application reports and the recommendation bythe Chief Planning Officer or other Chief Officers detailed in their reports on applications will be approved withoutdebate unless the Clerk to the meeting indicates otherwise during “Order of Business”at item 1.

4.1

Report for forthcoming application by the City of Edinburgh Council for Proposal of Application Notice at Trinity Academy, 1 Craighall Avenue, Edinburgh - Redevelopment of existing Trinity Academy and associated works including alteration of listed buildings (including retention and adaptation of the Victorian building and removal of 1950s /60s extensions), removal of all other existing buildings, and replacement with new school building as extension to the Victorian building and associated new landscaped outdoor areas. Associated buildings including temporary decant buildings on edge of site, relocation of services, alterations to boundary walls, new external works, and site access - application no. 23/01057/PAN - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 170 KB

It is recommended that the Committee notes key issues at this stage and advises of any other issues.

Additional documents:

4.2

44 Biggar Road, Edinburgh, EH10 7BJ - Section 42 application seeking to reword condition 7 attached to planning permission ref. 12/00758/FUL, to allow the sale of convenience goods from 248sqm gross sales floorspace at the site - application no. 22/04184/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 104 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

4.3

2 & 4 Canning Street Lane, Edinburgh, EH3 8ER - Change of use from residential to serviced apartments (sui-generis) - application no. 22/04304/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 105 KB

It is recommended that this application be REFUSED.

 

Additional documents:

4.4

1 East Rigg Farm, Balerno, EH14 7JR - Erect 3x holiday huts and associated works - application no. 22/06141/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 111 KB

It is recommended that this application be REFUSED.

 

Additional documents:

4.5

159 Fountainbridge, Edinburgh (Site At Former) - Approval of matters specified in conditions 1 (a-m) and (i)-(v), 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, of PPP application ref: 19/03097/PPP, relating to plots W1-W4 including residential/commercial/retail units; detail of height, massing, ground floor levels, design of external features and materials including public realm, pedestrian and cycle access arrangements, treatment to adopted roads or footways, car parking venting, servicing, surface water and drainage, lighting, waste management and hard and soft landscaping details (as amended) - application no. 22/04045/AMC - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 271 KB

It is recommended that this application be APPROVED.

 

Additional documents:

4.6

10 Gilmerton Station Road, Edinburgh (At Land 292 Metres West Of) - Proposed residential development, including bike/bin stores, associated infrastructure, access, landscaping and engineering works - application no. 22/02912/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 179 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

Additional documents:

4.7

5B Hope Terrace, Edinburgh, EH9 2AP - Erect dwelling - application no. 22/06107/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 121 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

4.8

4 Oversman Road (Land 160 Metres Northeast Of), Edinburgh - Proposed development of three detached business and industrial units, including trade counter (use Classes 4, 5 and 6) and Sui Generis car showroom with associated access, car parking and landscaping - application no. 22/05666/PPP - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 137 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

4.9

Confirmation of Tree Preservation Order No. 202 (Ravelston Dykes Road) - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 681 KB

It is recommended that the order be CONFIRMED.

Additional documents:

4.29

4 Sunbury Street, Edinburgh, EH4 3BU - Retrospective change of use from residential to short term let (Sui-Generis) - application no. 22/04981/FULSTL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 99 KB

It is recommended that this application be REFUSED.

 

Additional documents:

5. Returning Applications

Additional documents:

These applications have been discussedpreviously bythe Sub- Committee.  A decision to grant, refuse or continueconsideration will be made following a presentation bythe Chief Planning Officer and discussion on each item.

 

5.1

7-7 A Newcraighall Road, Edinburgh, EH15 3HH - Residential development (as amended) - application no. 21/02559/PPP - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 48 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

5.2

10 Orchard Brae, Edinburgh, EH4 1PF - Proposed residential and office development comprising the change of use, extension and alteration of the existing office building to form residential accommodation and office/co-working space, demolition of the existing rear extension and erection of a new build residential development; with associated active travel routes, open space, parking and other infrastructure (as amended) - application no. 21/06512/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 58 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

5.3

28 St Andrew Square, Edinburgh, EH2 1AF - Proposed internal and external alterations to existing office building (class 4) to include removal of current extension and the provision of a new rear and rooftop extension, including cycle parking and associated facilities (as amended) - application no. 21/04282/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 62 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

 

Additional documents:

6. Applications for Hearing

Additional documents:

The Chief Planning Officer has identified the following applications as meeting the criteria for Hearings. The protocol note by the Head of Strategy and Insight sets out the procedure for the hearing.

6.1

43 Main Street, Edinburgh, EH4 5BZ - application no. 22/04940/FUL - Protocol Note by the Service Director – Legal and Assurance pdf icon PDF 147 KB

Additional documents:

6.2

43 Main Street, Edinburgh, EH4 5BZ - 48 bed care home at Main Street, Davidson's Mains, Edinburgh - application no. 22/04940/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 46 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

Additional documents:

6.3

139 Leith Walk, Edinburgh (At Land to East of) - application no. 22/01563/FUL - Protocol Note by the Service Director – Legal and Assurance pdf icon PDF 146 KB

Additional documents:

6.4

139 Leith Walk, Edinburgh (At Land to East of) - Demolition of the existing warehouse building and construction of Sui Generis flatted dwellings including mainstream, affordable and student accommodation with a ground floor commercial unit and associated infrastructure, landscaping, and a reconfiguration of the existing car park - application no. 22/01563/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 77 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

7. Applications for Detailed Presentation

Additional documents:

The Chief Planning Officer has identified the following applications for detailed presentation tothe Sub-Committee.  A decision to grant, refuse or continueconsideration will be made following the presentation and discussion on each item.

 

7.1

6 Bankhead Crossway South, Edinburgh, EH11 4EZ - Change of Use from warehouse to a swimming pool to train babies and children - application no. 22/05278/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 104 KB

It is recommended that this application be REFUSED.

 

Additional documents:

7.2

Bonnington Mains Quarry (At Land 177 Metres West of), Cliftonhall Road, Newbridge - Development of field for ancillary quarrying operations - application no. 22/02513/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 171 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

7.3

Bonnington Mains Quarry (At Land 177 Metres West of), Cliftonhall Road, Newbridge - Extraction of Quartz-Dolerite and erection of plant and ancillary structure (Section 42 Application to vary conditions 2, 13, 15, 16 and 18 of Planning Permission 17/05930/FUL) - application no. 22/02514/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer pdf icon PDF 186 KB

It is recommended that this application be GRANTED.

 

Additional documents:

8. Returning Applications Following Site Visit

Additional documents:

Theseapplicationshave beendiscussed at a previous meeting of the Sub-Committee and were continued to allowmembers to visit the sites. A decision to grant, refuse or continueconsideration will be made following a presentation bythe Chief Planning Officer and discussion on each item.

 

8.1

8.1

None.

Additional documents: